2017 NFL General Manager Rankings

2017 NFL General Manager Rankings:


(1) Bill Belichick (New England Patriots):

Team’s GM Since: 2000.

Best Draft Picks: Dont’a Hightower (2012 1st Round-25th overall), Devin McCourty (2010 1st Round-27th overall), Rob Gronkowski (2010 2nd Round-42nd overall), Julian Edelman (2009 7th Round-232nd overall), Stephen Gostkowski (2006 4th Round-118th overall), Logan Mankins (2005 1st Round-32nd overall), Vince Wilfork (2004 1st Round-21st overall), Tom Brady (2000 6th Round-199th overall).

Best Free Agent Signings: Rob Ninkovich, Mike Vrabel, and Rodney Harrison.

Best Trade: Getting Randy Moss from Oakland for a 4th round pick.


(2) John Schneider (Seattle Seahawks):

Team’s GM Since: 2010.

Best Draft Picks: Bruce Irvin (2012 1st Round-15th overall), Bobby Wagner (2012 2nd Round-47th overall), Russell Wilson (2012 3rd Round-75th overall), K.J. Wright (2011 4th Round-99th overall), Richard Sherman (2011 5th Round-154th overall), Malcolm Smith (2011 7th Round-242nd overall), Earl Thomas (2010 1st round-14th overall), Golden Tate (2010 2nd Round-60th overall), Kam Chancellor (2010 5th Round-133rd overall).

Best Free Agent Signings: Michael Bennett, Doug Baldwin (Undrafted FA), and Cliff Avril.

Best Trade: Trading Max Unger and a 1st round pick for Jimmy Graham and a 4th round pick.


(3) John Elway (Denver Broncos):

Team’s GM Since: 2011.

Best Draft Picks: Trevor Siemian (2015 7th Round-250th overall), Matt Paradis (2014 6th Round-207th overall), Derek Wolfe (2012 2nd Round-36th overall), Malik Jackson (2012 5th Round-137th overall), Danny Trevathan (2012 6th Round-188th overall), Von Miller (2011 1st Round-2nd overall), Julius Thomas (2011 4th Round-129th overall).

Best Free Agent Signings: Peyton Manning, DeMarcus Ware, Emmanuel Sanders, Aqib Talib, T.J. Ward, Chris Harris Jr (Undrafted FA).

Best Trade: Trading Tim Tebow.


(4) Ted Thompson (Green Bay Packers):

Team’s GM Since: 2005.

Best Draft Picks: David Bakhtiari (2013 4th Round-109th overall), Mike Daniels (2012 4th Round-132nd overall), Randall Cobb (2011 2nd Round-64th overall), Bryan Bulaga (2010 1st Round-23rd overall), Morgan Burnett (2010 3rd Round-71st overall), Clay Matthews (2009 1st Round-26th overall), T.J. Lang (2009 4th Round-109th overall), Jordy Nelson (2008 2nd Round-36th overall), Josh Sitton (2008 4th Round-135th overall), Mason Crosby (2007 6th Round-193rd overall), Greg Jennings (2006 2nd Round-52nd overall), Aaron Rodgers (2005 1st Round-24th overall).

Best Free Agent Signings: Charles Woodson, Julius Peppers, Sam Shields (Undrafted FA), John Kuhn, Ryan Pickett, Jared Cook.

Best Trade: Trading up for Clay Matthews.


(5) Ozzie Newsome (Baltimore Ravens):

Team’s GM Since: 1996 (was with Cleveland before than which turned into the Ravens).

Best Draft Picks: C.J. Mosley (2014 1st Round-17th overall), Rick Wagner (2013 5th Round-168th overall), Kelechi Osemele (2012 2nd Round-60th overall), Torrey Smith (2011 2nd Round-58th overall), Pernell McPhee (2011 5th Round-165th overall), Joe Flacco (2008 1st Round-18th overall), Marshal Yanda (2007 3rd Round-86th overall), Haloti Ngata (2006 1st Round-12th overall), Sam Koch (2006 6th Round-203rd overall), Terrell Suggs (2003 1st Round-10th overall) Ed Reed (2002 1st Round-24th overall), Jamal Lewis (2000 1st Round-5th overall), Jonathan Ogden (1996 1st Round-4th overall), Ray Lewis (1996 1st Round-26th overall).

Best Free Agent Signings: Shannon Sharpe and Matt Birk.

Best Trade: Trading up for Joe Flacco.


(6) Reggie McKenzie (Oakland Raiders):

Team’s GM Since: 2012.

Best Draft Picks: Amari Cooper (2015 1st Round-4th overall), Khalil Mack (2014 1st Round-5th overall), Derek Carr (2014 1st Round-36th overall), Gabe Jackson (2014 3rd Round-81st overall), Latavius Murray (2013 6th Round-181st overall).

Best Free Agent Signings: Kelechi Osemele, Donald Penn, Rodney Hudson, Michael Crabtree, and Reggie Nelson.

Best Trade: Trading for Marshawn Lynch.


(7) Kevin Colbert (Pittsburgh Steelers):

Team’s GM Since: Became GM officially in 2010 but has been in charge of personnel since 2000.

Best Draft Picks: Le’Veon Bell (2013 2nd Round-48th overall), David DeCastro (2012 1st Round-24th overall), Marcus Gilbert (2012 2nd Round-63rd overall), Maurkice Pouncey (2010 1st Round-18th overall), Emmanuel Sanders (2010 3rd Round-82nd overall), Antonio Brown (2010 6th Round-195th overall), Mike Wallace (2009 3rd Round-84th overall), Lawrence Timmons (2007 1st Round-15th overall), Lamarr Woodley (2007 2nd Round-46th overall), Santonio Holmes (2006 1st Round-25th overall), Heath Miller (2005 1st Round-30th overall), Ben Roethlisberger (2004 1st Round-11th overall), Troy Polamalu (2003 1st Round-16th overall).

Best Free Agent Signings: James Harrison, Ramon Foster (Undrafted FA), Alejandro Villanueva.

Best Trade: Trading Santonio Holmes.


(8) Thomas Dimitroff (Atlanta Falcons):

Team’s GM Since: 2008.

Best Draft Picks: Vic Beasley (2015 1st Round-8th overall), Tevin Coleman (2015 3rd Round-73rd overall), Desmond Trufant (2013 1st Round-22nd overall), Julio Jones (2011 1st Round-6th overall), Matt Ryan (2008 1st Round-3rd overall).

Best Free Agent Signings: Alex Mack, Taylor Gabriel (claimed off waivers), Jonathan Babineaux.

Best Trade: Trading up for Julio Jones.

(9) Howie Roseman (Philadelphia Eagles):

Team’s GM Since: 2010.

Best Draft Picks: Carson Wentz (2016 1st Round-2nd overall), Lane Johnson (2013 1st Round-4th overall), Zach Ertz (2013 2nd Round-35th overall), Bennie Logan (2013 3rd Round-67th overall), Fletcher Cox (2012 1st Round-12th overall), Jason Kelce (2011 6th Round-191st overall), Brandon Graham (2010 1st Round-13th overall).

Best Free Agent Signing: Evan Mathis.

Best Trade: Trading up for Carson Wentz.


(10) Jerry Jones (Dallas Cowboys):

Team’s GM Since: 1989.

Best Draft Picks: Ezekiel Elliott (2016 1st Round-4th overall), Dak Prescott (2016 4th Round-135th overall), Zack Martin (2014 1st Round-16th overall), Travis Frederick (2013 1st Round-31st overall), Tyron Smith (2011 1st Round-9th overall), Dez Bryant (2010 1st Round-24th overall), Sean Lee (2010 2nd Round-55th overall), DeMarcus Ware (2005 1st Round-11th overall), Jason Witten (2003 3rd Round-69th overall), Larry Allen (1994 2nd Round-46th overall), Emmitt Smith (1990 1st Round-17th overall), Troy Aikman (1989 1st Round-1st overall), Tony Tolbert (1989 4th Round-85th overall).

Best Free Agent Signings: Deion Lewis, Tony Romo (Undrafted FA), and Terrell Owens.

Best Trade: “The Herschel Walker Trade” (although Jimmy Johnson played a major role in this)


Honorable Mentions: Jon Robinson (Tennessee Titans), Rick Spielman (Minnesota Vikings), Steve Keim (Arizona Cardinals), Bob Quinn (Detroit Lions), John Lynch (San Francisco 49ers).

Future Five*: Eliot Wolf (Green Bay Packers), Nick Caserio (New England Patriots), Russ Ball (Green Bay Packers), George Paton (Minnesota Vikings), Peyton Manning (retired football player).

*to qualify for the Future Five you need to be in a NFL front office or a former player without ever having been a NFL GM.


Keegan Jackish

Keegan is an avid fan of both the NFL and College Football and is especially a fan of the Green Bay Packers and Big Ten football (except for Ohio State).

Latest posts by Keegan Jackish (see all)

Keegan Jackish

Keegan is an avid fan of both the NFL and College Football and is especially a fan of the Green Bay Packers and Big Ten football (except for Ohio State).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *